A Drug Case, a Bruno Mars Photo, and a Nurses’ Wage Case: Why Do They Share 17-cv-06350?

Updates
A Drug Case, a Bruno Mars Photo, and a Nurses’ Wage Case: Why Do They Share 17-cv-06350?

McFarlane v. Harry's Nurses Registry, an FLSA wage case filed by three Queens nurses on November 1, 2017, carries the number 17-cv-06350. The same number belongs to two earlier, unrelated cases: a Nexium death lawsuit and a copyright claim over a Bruno Mars photo. We compare their subject matter and ask how the later wage case got the same number.

Three cases. One docket number. One is a Nexium products liability case. The second is a copyright lawsuit over a Bruno Mars photo. The third is an FLSA wage case against Harry’s Nurses Registry.
Different Subject Matter
PRODUCTS LIABILITY
SUBJECT
Nexium, Wrongful Death
COURT
E.D. Tenn. → D.N.J.
FILED
Jun 22, 2017
COPYRIGHT
SUBJECT
Bruno Mars Photo
COURT
S.D. New York
FILED
Aug 21, 2017
LABOR LAW
SUBJECT
Unpaid Wages (FLSA)
COURT
E.D. New York
FILED
Nov 1, 2017
A Docket Number Shared Across Jurisdictions
These three cases were filed in three different federal courts over a five-month period in 2017. All of them carry the same docket number: 17-cv-06350. Within each court, a docket number identifies a single case, and federal courts use it to track every filing in that action.
i

Important

McCullough (June 22) and McGann (August 21) were both filed before McFarlane v. Harry’s Nurses Registry (November 1). Yet the later FLSA case carries the exact same number. Check the PACER results below, which list 10 entries under this number.
Search Query
Results
10 cases across multiple courts
Download PDF ↓
PDFPACER Case Locator Thumbnail
PACER Case Locator
10 results
The PACER search shows the number in courts from California to New Jersey. Below, we break down the three cases in the order they were filed, beginning with the earliest, in Tennessee.
Case No.
Court
Filed in E.D. Tennessee; listed in D.N.J.
Filed
June 22, 2017
Download PDF ↓
PDFComplaint Thumbnail
Complaint
Filed 06/22/17
Aubrey McCullough, for himself and the estate of Martha McCullough, sued AstraZeneca, claiming the heartburn drug Nexium caused kidney failure and death. The complaint relies on diversity jurisdiction, 28 U.S.C. § 1332. It is captioned for the Eastern District of Tennessee, while PACER lists the case in the District of New Jersey from August 22, 2017, where Judge Claire C. Cecchi and Magistrate Judge Mark Falk oversee the national Proton-Pump Inhibitor litigation (MDL 2789).
JUDGES
Hon. Claire C. Cecchi
Hon. Claire C. Cecchi
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, D.N.J. · CCC
Appointed Nominated by Barack Obama, December 2010; confirmed June 2011
Hon. Mark Falk
Hon. Mark Falk
U.S. MAGISTRATE JUDGE, D.N.J. · MF
Appointed January 2002; later Chief Magistrate Judge; retired September 2021
Case No.
Court
U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York
Filed
August 21, 2017
Download PDF ↓
PDFComplaint Thumbnail
Complaint
Filed 08/21/17
Photographer Catherine McGann sued Time Inc. for copyright infringement under 17 U.S.C. §§ 106 and 501. She claimed People.com published, without permission, her photo of singer Bruno Mars as a child Elvis impersonator. Jurisdiction rests on 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331 and 1338(a). She was represented by Richard P. Liebowitz of the Liebowitz Law Firm.
Case No.
Court
U.S. District Court, Eastern District of New York
Filed
November 1, 2017
Download PDF ↓
PDFComplaint Thumbnail
Complaint
Filed 11/01/17
Three licensed practical nurses, Marjorie McFarlane, Velma Palmer and Claire Williams, sued Harry’s Nurses Registry, Harry’s Homecare and the owner, named in the complaint as “Harry Dorvilien“, for minimum wage, overtime, wage notices and retaliation under the FLSA and New York Labor Law. They were represented by Michael P. Hilferty and Matthew Crawford of the Law Offices of Vincent P. White. The case was assigned to Judge Pamela K. Chen and Magistrate Judge Peggy Kuo. Notably, this FLSA lawsuit carries the same docket number as a products liability case and a copyright case that were both filed earlier.
JUDGES
Hon. Pamela K. Chen
Hon. Pamela K. Chen
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, E.D.N.Y. · PKC
Appointed Nominated by Barack Obama, August 2012; confirmed March 2013
Hon. Peggy Kuo
Hon. Peggy Kuo
U.S. MAGISTRATE JUDGE, E.D.N.Y. · PK
Appointed Sworn in October 9, 2015
The Subject Matter Jurisdiction Question
The subject matters have nothing in common. One case involves a prescription heartburn drug and a death, brought under diversity jurisdiction. The second involves a photographer’s copyright in a picture published on People.com. The third involves wages for nurses in Queens under the FLSA.
i

Important

If McFarlane is an FLSA case filed on November 1, 2017, what legal or administrative basis allowed it to carry the same number as two unrelated cases filed before it? The same pattern appears in Isigi v. Harry’s Nurses Registry, another FLSA case against the same defendants whose number, 16-cv-02218, was already in use by earlier unrelated filings.
CONCLUSION
In our view, when two FLSA cases against Harry’s Nurses Registry each take a docket number already used by unrelated, earlier cases, the question is not an isolated one. How these numbers were assigned, and whether each court’s subject matter jurisdiction was properly established, deserves a clear answer. In our view, giving McFarlane a number already used by unrelated cases violated the due process protections of the First, Sixth and Fourteenth Amendments.
Sources: PACER Case Locator; court filings above (E.D. Tenn., D.N.J., S.D.N.Y., E.D.N.Y.); District of New Jersey MDL 2789 orders.