Why Does an NYC Overtime Case Share Its Number With a Drug Lawsuit?

Updates
Why Does an NYC Overtime Case Share Its Number With a Drug Lawsuit?

Three federal cases in Louisiana, Illinois and New York, filed between May and July 2016, share docket number 16-cv-05677: a Xarelto products liability claim, a race discrimination lawsuit, and an FLSA overtime case against the City of New York. We compare their subject matter and ask how the later FLSA case came to carry the same number, a pattern also seen in Isigi v. Harry's Nurses Registry.

Three cases. One docket number. One is a Xarelto products liability case. The second is a race discrimination and retaliation lawsuit. The third is an FLSA overtime case.
Different Subject Matter
PRODUCTS LIABILITY
SUBJECT
Xarelto (blood thinner)
COURT
E.D. Louisiana (MDL 2592)
FILED
May 12, 2016
CIVIL RIGHTS
SUBJECT
Race Discrimination & Retaliation
COURT
N.D. Illinois
FILED
May 27, 2016
LABOR LAW
SUBJECT
Unpaid Overtime (FLSA)
COURT
S.D. New York
FILED
July 15, 2016
A Docket Number Shared Across Jurisdictions
These three cases were filed in three different federal districts over a two-month period in 2016. All of them carry the same docket number: 16-cv-05677. Within each court, a docket number identifies a single case, and federal courts use it to track every filing in that action.
i

Important

Zoellner (May 12) and Robinson (May 27) were both filed before Lynch v. City of New York (July 15). Yet the later FLSA case carries the exact same number. Check the PACER results below, which list 12 cases under this number.
Search Query
Results
12 cases across multiple districts
Download PDF ↓
PDFPACER Case Locator Thumbnail
PACER Case Locator
12 results
The PACER search shows the number in courts from Louisiana to Washington State. Below, we break down the three cases in the order they were filed, beginning with the earliest, in Louisiana.
Case No.
Court
U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Louisiana
Filed
May 12, 2016
Download PDF ↓
PDFShort Form Complaint Thumbnail
Short Form Complaint
Filed 05/12/16
This is a products liability claim over Xarelto (rivaroxaban), a blood thinner. Plaintiff Walter Zoellner joined the nationwide In re Xarelto litigation (MDL No. 2592) through a two-page Short Form Complaint filed by attorney Michael T. Gallagher of The Gallagher Law Firm, Houston. The case was before Judge Eldon E. Fallon and Magistrate Judge Michael B. North.
JUDGES
Hon. Eldon E. Fallon
Hon. Eldon E. Fallon
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, E.D. LA. · EEF
Appointed 1995, nominated by Bill Clinton; senior status since January 1, 2024
Hon. Michael B. North
Hon. Michael B. North
U.S. MAGISTRATE JUDGE, E.D. LA. · MBN
Appointed March 2014; Chief Magistrate Judge from July 2021
Case No.
Court
U.S. District Court, Northern District of Illinois
Filed
May 27, 2016
Download PDF ↓
PDFComplaint Thumbnail
Complaint
Filed 05/27/16
Suzette Robinson, Evanston’s former Director of Public Works, sued the City of Evanston, City Manager Walter Bobkiewicz, City Attorney W. Grant Farrar and HR manager Jennifer Lin for race discrimination, harassment and retaliation under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 and the Illinois Human Rights Act. She was represented by Cynthia H. Hyndman of Robinson Curley & Clayton. The case was assigned to Judge Sara L. Ellis.
JUDGE
Hon. Sara L. Ellis
Hon. Sara L. Ellis
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, N.D. ILL.
Appointed 2013, nominated by Barack Obama
Case No.
Court
U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York
Filed
July 15, 2016
Download PDF ↓
PDFComplaint Thumbnail
Complaint
Filed 07/15/16
This is a labor law dispute under the Fair Labor Standards Act. Employees of the city’s Department of Homeless Services claim they worked before and after their shifts and through meal periods without overtime pay. They were represented by Hope Pordy of Spivak Lipton LLP and Gregory K. McGillivary of Woodley & McGillivary LLP. The case was assigned to Judge Katherine B. Forrest. Notably, this FLSA lawsuit carries the same docket number as a products liability case and a civil rights case that were both filed earlier.
JUDGE
Hon. Katherine B. Forrest
Hon. Katherine B. Forrest
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, S.D.N.Y. · KBF
Appointed 2011, nominated by Barack Obama; resigned September 11, 2018
The Subject Matter Jurisdiction Question
The subject matters have nothing in common. One case involves a prescription blood thinner, and the court’s jurisdiction comes from a national multidistrict litigation in Louisiana. The second involves a city official in Illinois alleging race discrimination under the civil rights laws. The third involves overtime pay for city employees in New York under the FLSA.
i

Important

If Lynch is an FLSA case, what legal or administrative basis allowed it to carry the same number as two unrelated cases filed before it? The same pattern appears in Isigi v. Harry’s Nurses Registry, another FLSA case whose number, 16-cv-02218, was already in use by earlier unrelated filings.
CONCLUSION
In our view, when two FLSA cases each take a docket number already used by unrelated, earlier cases, the question is not an isolated one. How these numbers were assigned, and whether each court’s subject matter jurisdiction was properly established, deserves a clear answer. In our view, giving Lynch a number already used by unrelated cases violated the due process protections of the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments.
Sources: PACER Case Locator; court filings above (E.D. La., N.D. Ill., S.D.N.Y.); Federal Judicial Center biographies.