A Paycheck and a Child: Why Do Two Unrelated Cases Share 09-4113?
Updates
An FLSA wage case against a Manhattan day spa and a Native American child adoption case from Utah both carry the number 09-4113. We follow the number from the PACER results to the Tenth Circuit, and ask how a wage case came to share its number with another family's adoption case.
One number. Two very different cases. One is a wage-and-hour class action against a Manhattan day spa. The other is a Native American child adoption case that began in Utah.
|
LABOR LAW · FLSA
SUBJECT
Unpaid Wages
COURT
S.D. New York
FILED
Apr 27, 2009
|
CHILD ADOPTION · APPEAL
SUBJECT
Indian Child Welfare Act
COURT
Tenth Circuit
DOCKETED
Jun 9, 2009
|
WHERE IT STARTED
SUBJECT
Petition to Invalidate Adoption
COURT
D. Utah
FILED
Jun 25, 2008
|
A PACER search for 09cv4113 returns 14 cases. Among the district court filings, Battino v. Cornelia Fifth Avenue, filed April 27, 2009, comes first. But the same number also appears at the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, where Nielson v. Ketchum was docketed as No. 09-4113 on June 9, 2009.
i
Important
Nielson v. Ketchum is not a new case. It is the appeal of a child adoption dispute that was filed in Utah federal court on June 25, 2008, as 2:08-cv-00490-TS, ten months before Battino. The FLSA case in Manhattan and the adoption case from Utah now share the number 09-4113.
Twenty-eight former employees of the Cornelia Day Resort, a Fifth Avenue spa, sued its owners for unpaid wages and minimum wage under the FLSA, the New York Labor Law and ERISA. The plaintiffs were represented by Salvatore G. Gangemi and Jonathan Bernstein of Levy Davis & Maher, LLP. Bernstein also represented the plaintiffs in Gayle v. Harry’s Nurses Registry and Isigi v. Harry’s Nurses Registry. The complaint is stamped for Judge Paul G. Gardephe. Judge J. Paul Oetken decided summary judgment in 2012, and the case closed under Judge Lorna G. Schofield in 2014.
JUDGES
![]() |
Hon. Paul G. Gardephe
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, S.D.N.Y. · ORIGINALLY ASSIGNED
Appointed 2008, nominated by George W. Bush; senior status since August 9, 2023 |
![]() |
Hon. J. Paul Oetken
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, S.D.N.Y. · JPO
Appointed 2011, nominated by Barack Obama |
![]() |
Hon. Lorna G. Schofield
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, S.D.N.Y. · LGS
Appointed 2012, nominated by Barack Obama; senior status since January 1, 2025 |
This appeal came from the District of Utah, trial judge Ted Stewart. The question was whether the child, C.D.K., was an “Indian child” under the Indian Child Welfare Act when he was adopted. On April 5, 2011, a panel of Judges Hartz, Tacha and Ebel reversed the district court, holding that he was not. The Supreme Court denied review on May 21, 2012.
JUDGE
![]() |
Hon. David M. Ebel
U.S. CIRCUIT JUDGE, TENTH CIRCUIT · AUTHOR OF OPINION
Appointed 1988, nominated by Ronald Reagan; senior status since January 16, 2006 |
The birth mother, identified as B.J.N., asked the court to invalidate her consent and the adoption of her son by Sunny and Joshua Ketchum under the Indian Child Welfare Act, 25 U.S.C. §§ 1913(d) and 1914. She was represented by Paul Tsosie of Tsosie & Hatch, LLC. The case appears in the PACER results for 08cv00490 as Nielson v. Ketchum, assigned to Judge Ted Stewart.
JUDGE
![]() |
Hon. Ted Stewart
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, D. UTAH · TS
Appointed 1999, nominated by Bill Clinton; senior status since September 1, 2014 |
![]() |
ATTORNEY FOR THE PLAINTIFFS
Jonathan Bernstein
Levy Davis & Maher, LLP · New York |
The same attorney signed the complaint in each of these FLSA cases. Two were brought against Harry’s Nurses Registry, and the third is the case whose number, 09-4113, is shared with a child adoption appeal.
| Nov 7, 2007 | Gayle v. Harry’s Nurses Registry
FLSA wage case · E.D.N.Y. |
1:07-cv-04672 |
| Apr 27, 2009 | Battino v. Cornelia Fifth Avenue
FLSA wage case · S.D.N.Y. |
1:09-cv-04113 |
| May 3, 2016 | Isigi v. Harry’s Nurses Registry
FLSA wage case · E.D.N.Y. |
1:16-cv-02218 |
In our view, when one attorney appears at the center of every FLSA case in this series, his role in how these cases were filed and numbered deserves close examination.
The two cases rest on entirely different federal laws. Battino invokes the Fair Labor Standards Act, 29 U.S.C. § 216(b), to recover wages for spa workers in New York. The adoption case invokes the Indian Child Welfare Act, 25 U.S.C. § 1914, to challenge the adoption of a Cherokee descendant in Utah. One is about a paycheck. The other is about a child and his family.
i
Important
How does Battino, an FLSA case, carry the number 09-4113, a number that also belongs to someone else’s child adoption case, one that began in federal court ten months earlier? And why does the same plaintiffs’ attorney, Jonathan Bernstein, appear again, as he did in the FLSA cases against Harry’s Nurses Registry?
CONCLUSION
In our view, a wage case and a child adoption case have nothing in common but a number. When an FLSA case shares its number with an adoption case that belongs to another family, how the number was assigned and whether subject matter jurisdiction was properly established deserve a clear answer.
Sources: PACER Case Locator; court filings above (S.D.N.Y., D. Utah, 10th Cir.); Nielson v. Ketchum, 640 F.3d 1117 (10th Cir. 2011); Federal Judicial Center biographies. Private details of the minor child and family members have been blacked out.









