Malicious Prosecution by State Insurance Board
Updates
Harry’s Nurses Registry canceled its State Insurance Fund policy in 2007 and moved to AIG. Yet a federal lawsuit, Gayle v. Harry’s Nurses Registry, 1:07-cv-04672, and a Queens criminal indictment, 1709/2010, followed. According to Harry Dorvilier, another person’s criminal record was used against him without probable cause. He raises questions of federal jurisdiction, the Fourteenth Amendment, and Judge Tingling’s findings on the nurses.
SUMMARY
Harry’s Nurses Registry Inc. (HNR) officially requested the cancellation of its insurance policy with the state insurance board on May 29, 2007, and subsequently purchased a new policy from AIG. Given these circumstances, the state insurance board was not in a position to exercise authority or jurisdiction over HNR’s Workers’ Compensation fund. Despite this, the state insurance board, particularly its Inspector General Mr. William Gurin and the district attorney, misinterpreted the law. They initiated an inquiry approximately three years later, a move which contravened their jurisdictional bounds as HNR’s policy was now under AIG.
Adding to the complexity, private attorney Jonathan Bernstein filed a complaint against HNR on November 7, 2007, which Harry’s contends was fraudulent, only to withdraw his claims later in federal court. It is thus perplexing how the state insurance board could assert that a crime involving 13 individuals had been committed when they neither had the jurisdiction nor the consent for prosecution. This led to the district attorney prosecuting a crime under Section 31 of the Workers’ Compensation, and charging HNR with felonies. In our view, this action violates the 6th and 14th Amendments with regards to the rights of Harry’s Nurses Registry and its corporate officer, Mr. Harry Dorvilier.
Compounding the matter further, an additional 13 felonies were issued against Harry Dorvilier, each carrying a penalty of $26,000.00. This was done without properly defining a probable cause of action, which should have been determined by state or federal agencies through a comprehensive audit. Instead, Bernstein allegedly colluded with the presiding judge and obtained an order compelling HNR to produce a list of its associated nurses. Armed with this list, Bernstein privately contacted the nurses and influenced them to provide affidavits for submission to the court.
| 01 | The Documents |
The same two defendants, Harry Dorvilier and Harry’s Nurses Registry Inc., appear in both a state criminal case and a federal case.
![]() |
FROM STATE COURT
Indictment No. 1709/2010 · Queens County |
👤 PEOPLE IN THIS DOCUMENT
![]() |
Richard A. Brown
QUEENS COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY
Served 1991–2019; died May 2019
Prior Justice, Appellate Division, Second Department |
![]() |
Rosemary Buccheri
ASSISTANT DISTRICT ATTORNEY · ECONOMIC CRIMES BUREAU
Role Signed the 2010 alibi and discovery demands |
![]() |
Robert Schirtzer, Esq.
ATTORNEY FOR THE DEFENDANTS (2010)
Role Listed as defense counsel on the 2010 demands |
Demand for Discovery
Harry Dorvilier · Aug. 26, 2010
|
DOCUMENT 2
People v. Harry Dorvilier
|
Demand for Discovery
Harry’s Nurses Registry · Aug. 26, 2010
|
DOCUMENT 3
People v. Harry’s Nurses Registry Inc.
|
Decision and Order
Justice Margulis · Aug. 22, 2018
|
DOCUMENT 4
People v. Harry Dorvilier and Harry’s Nurses Registry, Inc.
|
👤 PEOPLE IN THIS DOCUMENT
![]() |
Hon. Ira H. Margulis
JUSTICE, SUPREME COURT, QUEENS COUNTY · 2018 DECISION
Served Supreme Court 2012–2023; Queens Criminal Court from 2003
Prior Assistant Queens County District Attorney from 1975 |
![]() |
FROM FEDERAL COURT
Gayle v. Harry’s Nurses Registry · 1:07-cv-04672-NGG-PK |
Affidavit of Service
Document 4 · Filed 11/29/07
|
DOCUMENT 5
Gayle v. Harry’s Nurses Registry · Affidavit of Service
|
👤 PEOPLE IN THIS DOCUMENT
![]() |
ATTORNEYS FOR THE PLAINTIFFS
Role Filed and served the summons and complaint, November 2007
Firm & Attorney Profiles (PDF) ↓ |
![]() |
Jonathan Bernstein
ATTORNEY · LEVY DAVIS MAHER & KLEIN LLP
Role Filed the complaint against HNR on November 7, 2007 |
![]() |
Hon. Nicholas G. Garaufis
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, E.D.N.Y. · NGG
Appointed 2000, nominated by Bill Clinton; senior status Oct. 1, 2014
Born 1948, Paterson, New Jersey
Education Columbia College, B.A., 1969; Columbia Law School, J.D., 1974 |
![]() |
Hon. Marilyn D. Go
U.S. MAGISTRATE JUDGE, E.D.N.Y. · MDG (ORIGINAL)
Served 1993–2019
Education Radcliffe College, B.A., 1973; Harvard Law School, J.D., 1977 |
![]() |
Hon. Peggy Kuo
U.S. MAGISTRATE JUDGE, E.D.N.Y. · PK (CURRENT DESIGNATION)
Appointed October 9, 2015
Education Yale University, B.A., 1985; Harvard Law School, J.D., 1988 |
Affidavit of Service
Document 3 · Filed 11/29/07
|
DOCUMENT 6
Gayle v. Harry’s Nurses Registry · Affidavit of Service
|
| 02 | Another Person’s Criminal Record |
Steen and the three partners from Levy Davis Maher & Klein LLP allegedly conspired with the U.S. Attorney General’s Office to obtain an indictment based on Injah Tafari’s criminal record and use it against Harry Dorvilier.
| “ | But Harry Dorvilier had no connection to that criminal record. So the question is: how could those criminal charges be used against him? |
In 2009, Harry Dorvilier filed a motion challenging the legal proceedings and raising concerns about violations of the Fair Labor Standards Act. He argued that the parties involved were working together with state authorities to pursue financial claims in federal court without a proper legal foundation.
| 03 | Subject-Matter Jurisdiction |
This raises a serious question about subject-matter jurisdiction.
| “ | Did the federal court have the legal authority to hear these claims, and were the necessary requirements established? |
According to Harry Dorvilier, the proceedings amounted to harassment and an improper attempt to obtain monetary damages through the federal court system. He also raised concerns under the Fourteenth Amendment, arguing that the use of another person’s criminal record violated his constitutional rights and that the criminal allegations lacked probable cause.
| 04 | William Gurin and the Insurance Policy |
Now, Mr. William Gurin is another important individual mentioned in these allegations. According to Harry Dorvilier, Mr. Gurin played a central role in coordinating the actions involving the New York State Insurance Fund.
The concerns also involved Mario Batali and the use of an insurance policy in connection with the legal proceedings. The argument was that a single insurance policy could not properly be used to support conflicting claims or proceedings without an appropriate legal basis.
PROFILE
![]() |
William Gurin
INSPECTOR GENERAL, NEW YORK STATE WORKERS’ COMPENSATION BOARD
Education City College of New York, B.A.; Columbia University, M.A.; Brooklyn Law School, J.D. |
Effie McCartney-Donaldson, who was the special assistant to the fraud inspector general of the state of New York, according to Harry Dorvilier, misrepresented as a government officer by saying that there is no workers’ compensation policy of Harry’s Nurses Registry, while HNR was engaged with AIG. On the other hand, HNR canceled the policy with the state insurance fund; therefore, in his view, they do not have jurisdiction over this matter after the cancelation and ruling by the Honorable Judge Tingling.
PROFILE
![]() |
Effie McCartney-Donaldson
SPECIAL ASSISTANT TO THE INSPECTOR GENERAL, NEW YORK STATE
Role State Insurance Fund matter, Harry’s Nurses Registry |
| 05 | The Decision Involving Judge Tingling |
This brings us to the decision involving Judge Tingling.
According to Harry Dorvilier, Judge Tingling determined that the nurses were independent contractors. That determination is important because the legal classification of workers can affect the applicability of employment laws, insurance coverage, and the rights and responsibilities of the parties involved.
Harry Dorvilier argues that the insurance policy should not have been used to pursue claims inconsistent with the court’s findings. Therefore, these issues should be brought before Judge Tingling for further examination.
PROFILE
![]() |
Hon. Milton A. Tingling, Jr.
FORMER JUSTICE, NEW YORK COUNTY SUPREME COURT · INDEX NO. 406555/07
Born 1954
Education Brown University, B.A.; North Carolina Central University School of Law, J.D.
Served Elected 2001; retired Dec. 31, 2014, to become New York County Clerk |
| 06 | Supporting Documents from the Record |
THE STATE INSURANCE FUND AND THE POLICY
|
STATE INSURANCE FUND AUDITOR
Affidavit of the State Insurance Board by Lauren Hill Stipulates That Nurses Are Independent Contractors
Download PDF ↓
|
||
|
PAYMENTS TO THE STATE INSURANCE FUND
The Canceled Insurance Policy and Copies of Checks Made to the State Insurance Fund
Download PDF ↓
|
||
JUDGE TINGLING
|
JUSTICE MILTON A. TINGLING, JR. · JULY 8, 2011
Decision and Order, Index No. 406555/07
Download PDF ↓
|
THE CRIMINAL CASE, INDICTMENT NO. 1709/2010
|
OFFICE OF THE DISTRICT ATTORNEY
Malicious Prosecution: Re: Harry’s Nurses Registry and Harry Dorvilier, Case IG #37534
Download PDF ↓
|
SUPREME COURT, QUEENS COUNTY · INDICTMENT NO. 1709/2010
Affidavit in Support: Fritznel J. Milfort, CPA
Download PDF ↓
|
|
|
WORKERS’ COMPENSATION BOARD, OFFICE OF THE FRAUD INSPECTOR GENERAL · FEB. 2, 2010
Referral Letter to ADA Rosemary Buccheri, Case IG #37534
Download PDF ↓
|
SUPREME COURT, QUEENS COUNTY · CRIMINAL TERM, PART K-23 · INDICTMENT NO. 1709/2010
Response to Defendants’ CPL 330 Motion
Download PDF ↓
|
👤 PEOPLE IN THIS DOCUMENT
![]() |
Rosemary Buccheri
ASSISTANT DISTRICT ATTORNEY · ECONOMIC CRIMES BUREAU
Role Signed the response to the defendants’ CPL 330 motion |
![]() |
Hon. Joel L. Blumenfeld
ACTING JUSTICE, SUPREME COURT, QUEENS COUNTY · TRIAL JUDGE
Served NYC Criminal Court from 1987; Acting Supreme Court Justice from 1991
Retired December 2015
Education Brooklyn College, B.A.; George Washington Law School, J.D. |
![]() |
Bernard Mitchell Alter
DEFENSE ATTORNEY AT TRIAL
Role Represented the defendants at the jury trial, Indictment 1709/2010 |
APPEALS
👤 PEOPLE IN THIS DOCUMENT
![]() |
Hon. Reinaldo E. Rivera
APPELLATE DIVISION, SECOND DEPT. · PRESIDING (J.P.)
Panel People v. Dorvilier appeal |
![]() |
Hon. L. Priscilla Hall
APPELLATE DIVISION, SECOND DEPT.
Panel People v. Dorvilier appeal |
![]() |
Hon. Leonard B. Austin
APPELLATE DIVISION, SECOND DEPT.
Panel People v. Dorvilier appeal |
![]() |
Hon. Jeffrey A. Cohen
APPELLATE DIVISION, SECOND DEPT.
Panel People v. Dorvilier appeal |
FEDERAL HABEAS
👤 PEOPLE IN THIS DOCUMENT
![]() |
Hon. Ann M. Donnelly
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, E.D.N.Y. · FEDERAL HABEAS
Appointed 2015, nominated by Barack Obama
Prior New York County District Attorney’s Office, 1984–2009; New York State Court of Claims, 2009–2015 |
LETTERS AND DEMANDS
THE FEDERAL CASE AND THE FAIR LABOR STANDARDS ACT
|
CITED CASE
Matter of David Gentile Nursing Services, P.C. v. Lillian Roberts, as Commissioner of Labor
Download PDF ↓
|
||
THE CENTRAL QUESTIONS
|
1 |
Were the proper legal procedures followed? |
|
2 |
Was there a valid basis for federal jurisdiction? |
|
3 |
Were the court’s findings regarding the nurses’ employment classification properly considered? |
These are the issues that need to be addressed before the court.





















































