Why Does a Dairy Queen Overtime Case Share Its Number With a Prisoner’s Petition?

Updates
Why Does a Dairy Queen Overtime Case Share Its Number With a Prisoner’s Petition?

Valdez v. Michpat & Fam, an FLSA overtime case against a Long Island Dairy Queen filed June 9, 2020, carries the number 20-cv-02570. Eight unrelated cases filed earlier that year share it, from 3M military earplug claims to a railroad price-fixing suit and a prisoner's habeas petition. We compare their subject matter and ask how the later wage case got the same number.

Nine cases. One docket number. Military earplugs, railroad price-fixing, facial recognition insurance, a deaf customer at a drive-thru, a prisoner’s habeas petition and an FLSA wage case against a Dairy Queen.
Different Subject Matter
🎧
PRODUCT LIABILITY
Military Combat Arms earplugs and hearing loss
FILED
Jan 28 – May 22
🚆
ANTITRUST
Rail fuel surcharge price-fixing under the Sherman Act
FILED
Mar 10, 2020
🛡️
INSURANCE
Insurance coverage for facial recognition privacy suits
FILED
Mar 25, 2020
🧏
DISABILITY ACCESS
Deaf customer at a Jack in the Box drive-thru
FILED
Apr 14, 2020
⚖️
HABEAS CORPUS
Federal prisoner petition under 28 U.S.C. § 2241
FILED
May 27, 2020
💵
FLSA WAGES
Overtime at a Long Island Dairy Queen
FILED
Jun 9, 2020
The Filing Timeline
Every case below carries 20-cv-02570 and links to its filing.
CASE NUMBER20-cv-02570 · 2020
Jan 28
Chaney v. 3M
Chaney v. 3M
Earplugs · N.D. Fla.
Feb 5
Hill v. 3M
Hill v. 3M
Earplugs · N.D. Fla.
Mar 10
Nippon Yusen v. BNSF Railway
Nippon Yusen v. BNSF Railway
Antitrust · D.N.J.
Mar 25
Twin City Fire v. Clearview AI
Twin City Fire v. Clearview AI
Insurance · S.D.N.Y.
Apr 14
Jensen v. SK Singh
Jensen v. SK Singh
Disability access · N.D. Cal.
May 22
Ballard v. 3M
Ballard v. 3M
Earplugs · N.D. Fla.
May 27
Luckenson v. United States
Luckenson v. United States
Habeas corpus · E.D. Pa.
Jun 9
Valdez v. Michpat & Fam
Valdez v. Michpat & Fam
FLSA overtime · E.D.N.Y.
A Docket Number Shared Across Jurisdictions
These cases were filed in six different federal courts in the first half of 2020. All of them carry the same docket number: 20-cv-02570. Within each court, a docket number identifies a single case, and federal courts use it to track every filing in that action.
i

Important

Valdez v. Michpat & Fam, an FLSA wage case, carries the exact same number as earplug, antitrust, insurance, disability and habeas cases in other federal courts. Check the PACER results below, which list 33 entries under this number.
Search Query
Results
33 cases across multiple courts
Download PDF ↓
PDFPACER Case Locator Thumbnail
PACER Case Locator
33 results
Below, we break down each case, beginning in Florida.
Case No.
Court
U.S. District Court, Northern District of Florida
Filed
January 28, 2020
Download PDF ↓
PDFMaster Short Form Complaint Thumbnail
Master Short Form Complaint
Filed 01/28/20
This is a products liability claim in the nationwide In re 3M Combat Arms Earplug litigation (MDL No. 2885). Using a six-page Short Form Complaint, the plaintiff claims that 3M’s dual-ended Combat Arms earplugs caused hearing loss. Two more earplug cases in the same court carry the same number: Hill v. 3M (3:20-cv-02570, filed February 5, 2020) and Ballard v. 3M (8:20-cv-02570, filed May 22, 2020). All three are before Judge M. Casey Rodgers and Magistrate Judge Gary R. Jones.
JUDGES
Hon. M. Casey Rodgers
Hon. M. Casey Rodgers
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, N.D. FLA. · MCR
Appointed 2003, nominated by George W. Bush; Chief Judge 2011–2018
Hon. Gary R. Jones
Hon. Gary R. Jones
U.S. MAGISTRATE JUDGE, N.D. FLA. · GRJ
Appointed 2010; now retired, serving on recall
Case No.
Court
U.S. District Court, District of New Jersey
Filed
March 10, 2020
Download PDF ↓
PDFComplaint and Jury Demand Thumbnail
Complaint and Jury Demand
Filed 03/10/20
Japanese shipping company NYK Line sued BNSF Railway and Union Pacific under Section 1 of the Sherman Act, claiming the railroads conspired to fix rail fuel surcharges for more than a decade. It was filed by Stephanie A. Ackerman of Baker & Hostetler LLP. PACER shows the New Jersey case closed on March 23, 2020, with a matching entry before the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation. It was assigned to Judge Claire C. Cecchi and Magistrate Judge Edward S. Kiel.
JUDGES
Hon. Claire C. Cecchi
Hon. Claire C. Cecchi
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, D.N.J. · CCC
Appointed Nominated by Barack Obama, December 2010; confirmed June 2011
Hon. Edward S. Kiel
Hon. Edward S. Kiel
U.S. MAGISTRATE JUDGE, D.N.J. · ESK
Appointed Magistrate Judge 2019; U.S. District Judge since 2024, nominated by Joe Biden
Case No.
Court
U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York
Filed
March 25, 2020
Download PDF ↓
PDFComplaint for Declaratory Judgment Thumbnail
Complaint for Declaratory Judgment
Filed 03/26/20
Insurer Twin City Fire asked the court to declare, under 28 U.S.C. § 2201, that it owed no duty to defend or indemnify facial recognition company Clearview AI and its founders in six privacy class actions. It was filed by Wilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker LLP. PACER shows the case closed on April 3, 2020. It was assigned to Judge Philip M. Halpern.
JUDGE
Hon. Philip M. Halpern
Hon. Philip M. Halpern
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, S.D.N.Y. · PMH
Appointed Nominated by Donald Trump; commissioned February 21, 2020
Case No.
Court
U.S. District Court, Northern District of California
Filed
April 14, 2020
Download PDF ↓
PDFComplaint Thumbnail
Complaint
Filed 04/14/20
ReVae Jensen, who is profoundly deaf and communicates in American Sign Language, sued the operator of a Jack in the Box restaurant over access to its drive-thru under disability rights laws. She was represented by Andrew Rozynski of Eisenberg & Baum, LLP. The caption reads 5:20-cv-2570, while the court’s stamp reads 3:20-cv-02570-WHO. It was assigned to Judge William H. Orrick.
JUDGE
Hon. William H. Orrick
Hon. William H. Orrick
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, N.D. CAL. · WHO
Appointed 2013, nominated by Barack Obama
Case No.
Court
U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Pennsylvania
Filed
May 27, 2020
Download PDF ↓
PDFHabeas Corpus Petition Thumbnail
Habeas Corpus Petition
Filed 05/27/20
Federal prisoner Dorceant Luckenson, without a lawyer, filed a habeas corpus petition under 28 U.S.C. § 2241 challenging the court’s jurisdiction over his earlier criminal conviction. PACER shows the case closed on June 3, 2020, one week later. It was assigned to Judge C. Darnell Jones II. His prison register number has been blacked out.
JUDGE
Hon. C. Darnell Jones II
Hon. C. Darnell Jones II
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, E.D. PA. · CDJ
Appointed 2008, nominated by George W. Bush; senior status since March 15, 2021
Case No.
Court
U.S. District Court, Eastern District of New York
Filed
June 9, 2020
Download PDF ↓
PDFComplaint Thumbnail
Complaint
Filed 06/09/20
Jessica Valdez, a former hourly worker and manager at a Dairy Queen franchise in Medford, Long Island, sued the owner, Michpat & Fam, LLC, and its managing member Patricia Nappo (Demint) for unpaid overtime and minimum wage under the FLSA and New York Labor Law. She was represented by Michael R. Minkoff, Alexander T. Coleman and Michael J. Borrelli of Borrelli & Associates, P.L.L.C. The case was assigned to Judge Ann M. Donnelly and Magistrate Judge Steven I. Locke, and on March 30, 2022, Judge Donnelly adopted Judge Locke’s recommendation on collective and class certification. Notably, this FLSA lawsuit carries the same docket number as earplug, antitrust, insurance, disability and habeas cases in other courts.
JUDGES
Hon. Ann M. Donnelly
Hon. Ann M. Donnelly
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, E.D.N.Y. · AMD
Appointed 2015, nominated by Barack Obama
Hon. Steven I. Locke
Hon. Steven I. Locke
U.S. MAGISTRATE JUDGE, E.D.N.Y. · SIL
Appointed August 1, 2014; reappointed 2022
The Subject Matter Jurisdiction Question
The subject matters have nothing in common. The earplug cases rest on product liability claims gathered in a national MDL. NYK’s case rests on the Sherman Act, Twin City’s on the Declaratory Judgment Act, Jensen’s on disability rights law, and Luckenson’s on habeas corpus. Valdez rests on the FLSA, 29 U.S.C. § 201 et seq., with the New York claims under supplemental jurisdiction, 28 U.S.C. § 1367.
i

Important

If Valdez is an FLSA case, what legal or administrative basis allowed it to carry the same number as these unrelated cases? The same pattern appears in Isigi v. Harry’s Nurses Registry, another FLSA case whose number, 16-cv-02218, is shared with unrelated filings.
CONCLUSION
In our view, when FLSA cases repeatedly take a docket number also used by unrelated cases, the question is not an isolated one. How these numbers were assigned, and whether each court’s subject matter jurisdiction was properly established, deserves a clear answer. In our view, giving Valdez a number also used by unrelated cases violated the due process protections of the First, Sixth and Fourteenth Amendments.
Sources: PACER Case Locator; court filings above (N.D. Fla., D.N.J., S.D.N.Y., N.D. Cal., E.D. Pa., E.D.N.Y.); Federal Judicial Center biographies.