Why Does a Wrongful Death Suit Share a Number with an FLSA Case?

Updates
Why Does a Wrongful Death Suit Share a Number with an FLSA Case?

A review of federal court records reveals a glaring administrative anomaly: Docket Number 16-cv-02218 was assigned to three entirely unrelated lawsuits across three different jurisdictions—a wrongful death products liability suit in Illinois, a trademark/RICO dispute in Manhattan, and an FLSA overtime case in Brooklyn.

Three cases. Three different subject matters. One is a wrongful death products liability case. The second is a trademark/RICO dispute. The third is an FLSA overtime case.
Different Subject Matter
PRODUCTS LIABILITY
SUBJECT
Wrongful Death
COURT
N.D. Illinois
FILED
Feb 12, 2016
TRADEMARK / RICO
SUBJECT
Lanham Act
COURT
S.D. New York
FILED
Mar 25, 2016
LABOR LAW
SUBJECT
Unpaid Overtime
COURT
E.D. New York
FILED
May 3, 2016
A Docket Number Shared Across Jurisdictions
These three cases were filed in three different federal districts over a three-month period in 2016. Yet, they all share the exact same docket number: 16-cv-02218. In the federal court system, a docket number is the unique identifier for a specific legal action.
i

Important

In our view, the products liability record of Buccy v. Abbott was filed months before the FLSA case of Isigi v. Harry’s Nurses, yet they share the exact same docket number. Check the court records below to verify how this overlap occurred.
Search Query
Results
39 cases across multiple districts
Download PDF ↓
PDF PACER Search Results Thumbnail
PACER Case Locator
39 results
The PACER search confirms that these filings are not an isolated error. To understand the scope of this anomaly, we break down the details of the three cases that share this exact docket number, beginning with the earliest filing in Illinois.
Case No.
Court
U.S. District Court, Northern District of Illinois
Filed
February 12, 2016
Download PDF ↓
PDF Buccy Complaint Thumbnail
Complaint
Filed 02/12/16
This case involves a wrongful death and products liability lawsuit against Abbott Laboratories and others. The plaintiffs allege that defective blood glucose test strips led to a fatal car crash in Texas. The proceedings are overseen by U.S. District Judge Sharon Johnson Coleman, whose profile is detailed below.
JUDGE
Hon. Sharon Johnson Coleman
Hon. Sharon Johnson Coleman
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, N.D. ILL.
Appointed 2010, nominated by Barack Obama
Case No.
Court
U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York
Filed
March 25, 2016
Download PDF ↓
PDF Manchanda Notice of Removal Thumbnail
Notice of Removal
Filed 03/25/16
This action is a trademark and civil RICO dispute removed from the Civil Court of the City of New York, County of New York (Index No. 003665/2016). The plaintiff, Rahul Manchanda, represents himself (pro se) against News Corp and Rebecca Rosenberg. The case is assigned to U.S. District Judge Andrew L. Carter Jr., detailed below.
JUDGE
Hon. Andrew L. Carter Jr.
Hon. Andrew L. Carter Jr.
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, S.D.N.Y.
Appointed August 2011, nominated by Barack Obama
Case No.
Court
U.S. District Court, Eastern District of New York
Filed
May 3, 2016
Download PDF ↓
PDF Isigi Complaint Thumbnail
Complaint
Filed 05/03/16
This is a labor law dispute involving allegations of unpaid overtime under the FLSA and NYLL. The plaintiff is represented by attorney Jonathan A. Bernstein, and the case is presided over by U.S. District Judge Frederic Block and Magistrate Judge Steven M. Gold. Notably, this FLSA lawsuit assumes the docket number of an entirely unrelated products liability case, raising pressing questions about how it was assigned to this specific court record.
JUDGE & ATTORNEYS
Hon. Frederic Block
Hon. Frederic Block
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, E.D.N.Y. · FB
Appointed 1994, nominated by Bill Clinton
Hon. Steven M. Gold
Hon. Steven M. Gold
U.S. MAGISTRATE JUDGE, E.D.N.Y. · SMG
Appointed 1993, served as Chief Magistrate Judge from 2002 to 2005
Jonathan A. Bernstein
Jonathan A. Bernstein
ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF
Firm Levy Davis & Maher, LLP
The Subject Matter Jurisdiction Question
When comparing these filings, a glaring question arises regarding the administrative assignment of these docket numbers. The subject matters are entirely disparate: one involves a defective medical device causing a fatal car crash in Texas; another involves a newspaper and trademark/RICO claims in New York; and the third involves unpaid overtime for a nurse in Queens.
i

Important

If Isigi is an FLSA case, what legal or administrative basis allowed its docket number to be shared with a products liability case filed months earlier in a different circuit? The PACER results prove this is not an isolated error.
CONCLUSION
Ultimately, these procedural irregularities—including the lack of proper administrative oversight, the absence of a valid statutory foundation, and the assignment of identical docket numbers to unrelated matters—directly violated the constitutional rights of Harry Dorvilier and Harry’s Nurses Registry, Inc. under the First, Sixth, and Fourteenth Amendments.
Sources: PACER Case Locator; court filings above (E.D.N.Y., S.D.N.Y., N.D. Ill.).