======================================== POST #31 ======================================== Title: How a Murder Case Number Reached Mario Batali’s FLSA Case? Slug: how-a-murder-case-number-reached-mario-batalis-flsa-case-31 Date: 2026-11-12 16:33:50 Status: publish Category: 2 YouTube: Image: https://hnrlawlibrary.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/batali-feature-photo-v4.jpg ======================================== --- SHORT SUMMARY --- A Michigan murder case and Mario Batali’s fair labor case have two different subject matters. In our view, the criminal record of Dunigan v. Washington, a murder habeas case, was served to Batali’s FLSA case, Capsolas v. Pasta Resources Inc., 1:10-cv-05595, which settled for $5.25 million. We ask what legal basis supported the claims and the settlement. --- CONTENT ---
Two cases. Two different subject matters. One is a murder case. The other is Mario Batali's fair labor case, settled for $5.25 million.
01
Different Subject Matter
CRIMINAL
Dunigan v. Washington
2:09-cv-11476
SUBJECT
Murder conviction
LAW
28 U.S.C. § 2254, habeas corpus
COURT
E.D. Michigan
FILED
April 20, 2009
CIVIL
Capsolas v. Pasta Resources
1:10-cv-05595
SUBJECT
Mario Batali · wages and tips
LAW
29 U.S.C. § 216(b), FLSA
COURT
S.D. New York
FILED
July 22, 2010 · $5.25M
A state criminal conviction, a federal habeas corpus petition, and a civil action are legally distinct proceedings. Each must have an appropriate jurisdictional basis.
02
A Murder Case Record Served to Mario Batali
This case originally began in the State of Michigan, where a woman was convicted of murder and sentenced to prison. She later filed a federal petition for a writ of habeas corpus under 28 U.S.C. § 2254, claiming that her state conviction was unlawful and that her constitutional rights had been violated.
In our view, the criminal record of Dunigan v. Washington, a murder habeas case, was served to Mario Batali's fair labor case through the trail of case numbers below.
STEP 1
People v. Teresa Ann Dunigan-Snell
CASE NO. No. 280522
COURT Michigan Court of Appeals, from Kalamazoo Circuit Court (LC No. 07-000199-FC)
DECIDED October 23, 2008
SUBJECT Second-degree murder and perjury convictions, affirmed
Court of Appeals Opinion, page 1
Court of Appeals Opinion
Unpublished · 3 pages
JUDGES
Hon. Deborah A. Servitto
Hon. Deborah A. Servitto
MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS · PRESIDING JUDGE
Served  2006–2024; appointed March 2006
Education  Oakland University
Hon. Pat M. Donofrio
Hon. Pat M. Donofrio
MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS
Served  2002–2015; retired Sept. 30, 2015
Prior  Macomb County Circuit Court judge
Education  Wayne State University, B.S.
Hon. Karen Fort Hood
Hon. Karen Fort Hood
MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS
Served  2003–2021; died Aug. 15, 2021
Prior  Wayne County Circuit Court, 1998–2003; Recorder's Court, 1992–1998
Education  Regents College, B.A.; Detroit College of Law, J.D.
STEP 2
Dunigan v. Washington
CASE NO. 2:09-cv-11476-DPH-RSW
COURT U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Michigan
FILED April 20, 2009
DOCUMENT Petition for writ of habeas corpus, 28 U.S.C. § 2254
Habeas Petition, page 1
Habeas Petition
ECF No. 1 · Filed 04/20/09
JUDGES
Hon. Denise Page Hood
Hon. Denise Page Hood
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, E.D. MICH. · DPH
Appointed  1994, nominated by Bill Clinton; chief judge 2015–2022; senior status May 1, 2022
Born  1952, Columbus, Ohio
Education  Yale University, B.A., 1974; Columbia Law School, J.D., 1977
Hon. R. Steven Whalen
Hon. R. Steven Whalen
U.S. MAGISTRATE JUDGE, E.D. MICH. · RSW
Served  2002–2021; executive magistrate judge from Nov. 2003
Education  University of Illinois; Wayne State University Law School
STEP 3
PACER Search: 09cv11476
SEARCH 09cv11476
RESULTS 3 cases, including Dunigan v. Washington, E.D. Michigan
NOTE Same digits as Seger's state case number, 09-CI-011476
PACER Case Locator, page 1
PACER Case Locator
3 results · account details removed
STEP 4
Seger v. Kentucky High School Athletic Ass'n
CASE NO. 3:09-cv-00967
COURT U.S. District Court, Western District of Kentucky (Louisville)
FILED December 14, 2009
DOCUMENT Notice of Removal, Document 1
FROM Jefferson Circuit Court, Civil Action No. 09-CI-011476
Notice of Removal, page 1
Notice of Removal
Document 1 · Filed 12/14/09
JUDGE
Hon. John G. Heyburn II
Hon. John G. Heyburn II
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, W.D. KY. · JGH
Appointed  1992, nominated by George H.W. Bush; chief judge 2001–2008
Born  1948, Boston; died April 29, 2015
Education  Harvard College, A.B., 1970; University of Kentucky, J.D., 1976
STEP 5
PACER Search: 09cv00967
SEARCH 09cv00967
RESULTS 56 cases, including Seger v. Kentucky High School Athletic, W.D. Kentucky
DATES Filed 12/14/2009 · closed 04/20/2010
PACER Case Locator, page 1
PACER Case Locator
56 results · account details removed
STEP 6
Seger v. Kentucky High School Athletic Ass'n
CASE NO. 10-5595
COURT U.S. Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit
FILED May 19, 2010
DOCUMENT Docketing letter, Document 1
ORIGIN Originating Case No. 09-00967
Appeal Docketing Letter, page 1
Appeal Docketing Letter
Document 1 · Filed 05/19/10
JUDGES
Hon. Julia Smith Gibbons
Hon. Julia Smith Gibbons
CIRCUIT JUDGE, 6TH CIR. · WROTE THE OPINION
Appointed  2002, nominated by George W. Bush
Education  Vanderbilt, B.A.; University of Virginia, J.D.
Hon. Jeffrey S. Sutton
Hon. Jeffrey S. Sutton
CIRCUIT JUDGE, 6TH CIR.
Appointed  2003, nominated by George W. Bush
Education  Williams College, B.A.; Ohio State, J.D.
Hon. John R. Adams
Hon. John R. Adams
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, N.D. OHIO · SITTING BY DESIGNATION
Appointed  2003, nominated by George W. Bush
Education  Bowling Green State, B.S.; University of Akron, J.D.
STEP 7
PACER Search: 10cv5595
SEARCH 10cv5595
RESULTS 9 cases, including Seger (Sixth Circuit) and Capsolas (S.D. New York)
PACER Case Locator, page 1
PACER Case Locator
9 results · account details removed
STEP 8
Capsolas v. Pasta Resources Inc. (Mario Batali)
CASE NO. 1:10-cv-05595-SDA
COURT U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York
FILED July 22, 2010
CLAIM Fair Labor Standards Act, 29 U.S.C. § 216(b)
OUTCOME Settled for $5.25 million
Complaint, page 1
Complaint
Document 1 · Filed 07/22/10
JUDGES
Hon. Richard J. Holwell
Hon. Richard J. Holwell
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE, S.D.N.Y. · ASSIGNED JUDGE (RJH)
Appointed  2003, nominated by George W. Bush; resigned 2012
Born  1946, New York
Education  Villanova, B.A.; Columbia Law School, J.D.
Hon. Stewart D. Aaron
Hon. Stewart D. Aaron
U.S. MAGISTRATE JUDGE, S.D.N.Y. · CURRENT DESIGNATION (SDA)
Appointed  December 2017
Education  Cornell, B.S.; Syracuse Law, J.D.
How does a case originating from a state criminal conviction move through the federal courts, receive different case numbers, and eventually return to the district court?
03
The FLSA Question
Under 29 U.S.C. § 216(a), certain willful violations of the Fair Labor Standards Act may result in criminal penalties. Section 216(b) establishes a private right of action for unpaid wages and overtime. Sections 206 and 207 set minimum wage and overtime requirements, and Section 255 sets the statute of limitations.
If there was no underlying violation of the Fair Labor Standards Act, what legal basis supported the claims and the $5.25 million settlement?
CONCLUSION
The central concern is whether the proper legal procedures were followed, whether the claims had a valid statutory foundation, and whether the court acted within its lawful authority.
Sources: PACER Case Locator (account details removed); court filings above; Justia; Eater NY; CBS News.
--- META --- Array ( [images] => Array ( ) [pdfs] => Array ( ) )