======================================== POST #29 ======================================== Title: Violation of the Fourteenth Amendment: Two Different Subject Matters Under One Number, 1:23-cv-03773 Slug: violation-of-the-fourteenth-amendment-two-different-subject-matters-under-one-number-123-cv-03773-29 Date: 2026-11-10 17:33:31 Status: publish Category: 2 YouTube: Image: https://hnrlawlibrary.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/fourteenth-amendment-feature-v2.jpg ======================================== --- SHORT SUMMARY --- Donald Trump’s hush-money case started in New York state court as a criminal indictment. When he moved it to federal court, it got a civil number, 1:23-cv-03773, which a Brooklyn court also gave to an unrelated copyright lawsuit. Two different subject matters share one number. We argue the state lacked proper jurisdiction, which violated Trump’s right to due process under the Fourteenth Amendment. --- CONTENT ---
One number, 1:23-cv-03773, links three courts: a state criminal case against Donald J. Trump, a federal removal in Manhattan, and a copyright lawsuit in Brooklyn. Does the jurisdiction add up?
Diagram: state indictment, Manhattan federal removal and Brooklyn copyright case sharing number 1:23-cv-03773

Where It Started: The State Indictment

In March 2023, a Manhattan grand jury indicted Trump on 34 counts of falsifying business records. The records showed 2017 payments to his lawyer, Michael Cohen, as legal expenses. The DA said they repaid a hush-money payment to Stormy Daniels.
State Indictment No.
Supreme Court of the State of New York · New York County
Judge Hon. Juan M. Merchan, N.Y. Supreme Court
Prosecutor Manhattan District Attorney Alvin L. Bragg
Charges 34 counts, falsifying business records in the first degree
Law N.Y. Penal Law § 175.10, a state crime
"Other crime" claimed "Attempts to violate state and federal election laws," with no specific crime named in the indictment
Court Filing
Statement of Facts, page 1
Statement of Facts
IND-71543-23 · Apr. 4, 2023

The Move to Federal Court

On May 4, 2023, Trump asked the Manhattan federal court to take the case, arguing he acted as President and that federal election law overrides the state's theory. The court opened the criminal case under a civil number and sent it back to state court three times.
Case No.
U.S. District Court · Southern District of New York (Manhattan)
Filed May 4, 2023
Nature of Proceeding Notice of Removal of a state criminal case
Removed From Supreme Court of the State of New York, New York County · Ind. No. 71543-23
Filing Party Donald J. Trump
Other Party The People of the State of New York (Manhattan District Attorney)
Court Filing
Notice of Removal, page 1
Notice of Removal
Document 1 · Filed 05/04/23
Judge
Hon. Alvin K. Hellerstein
Hon. Alvin K. Hellerstein
Senior U.S. District Judge, S.D.N.Y. · Presiding judge (AKH)
Appointed President Clinton, 1998
Born 1933, New York, NY · died Oct. 28, 2026
Education Columbia College (B.A.); Columbia Law (J.D.)
Prior Service U.S. Army JAG Corps; private practice, New York
Courthouse 500 Pearl Street, Manhattan

The Same Number in Brooklyn

Fifteen days later, the Brooklyn federal court gave the same number to Strike 3 Holdings v. John Doe, a civil suit over 30 films shared online. It has no connection to Trump.
Case No.
U.S. District Court · Eastern District of New York (Brooklyn)
Filed May 19, 2023
Nature of Suit 820 · Copyright
Plaintiff Strike 3 Holdings, LLC (Delaware)
Defendant John Doe, known only by an IP address (Verizon Fios subscriber, Kings County)
Plaintiff's Attorney John C. Atkin, The Atkin Firm, LLC
Court Filing
Complaint, page 1
Complaint
Document 1 · Filed 05/19/23
Judges
Hon. Orelia E. Merchant
Hon. Orelia E. Merchant
U.S. District Judge, E.D.N.Y. · Assigned judge (OEM)
Appointed President Biden, 2023
Born 1971, Bronx, NY
Education Dillard (B.S.); William & Mary (M.A.); Tulane Law (J.D.)
Prior Service Asst. U.S. Attorney, E.D.N.Y.; Chief Deputy AG, New York
Courthouse 225 Cadman Plaza East, Brooklyn
Hon. Taryn A. Merkl
Hon. Taryn A. Merkl
U.S. Magistrate Judge, E.D.N.Y. · Pretrial matters (TAM)
Appointed Board of Judges, E.D.N.Y., 2021
Born Not publicly listed
Education Univ. of Michigan (B.A.); Columbia Law (J.D.)
Prior Service Asst. U.S. Attorney, E.D.N.Y.; Brennan Center
Courthouse 225 Cadman Plaza East, Brooklyn

Our Argument

1
The state case rested on a federal question. The felony charge needed "another crime," and the indictment pointed to election laws tied to a federal race without naming a specific crime (PBS Frontline). In our view, federal money questions belong to federal authorities, not a county DA.
2
The checks were legal expenses on paper. They were paid to Trump's attorney and recorded that way. The felony depended on calling them something else.
3
A criminal case got a civil number. In federal court the prosecution was filed as 23-cv-3773, a civil docket, not a criminal "cr" docket.
4
That number also belongs to a copyright case. A hush-money prosecution and a copyright suit share no subject matter, yet one number points to both. The system does not add up.

What the Courts Said

  • Judge Hellerstein ruled three times that the payments were private acts, not official ones, and kept the case in state court.
  • Each federal court numbers its own cases, which is why the number repeats. Trump was convicted in May 2024 and is appealing.

Conclusion

Trump's case started in state court, moved to federal court under a civil number, and that same number went to an unrelated copyright case. Different subject matter, different laws, different judges. In our view, the system does not add up. Prosecuting a person in a court without proper subject-matter jurisdiction violates his right to due process under the Fourteenth Amendment, which bars any state from depriving a person of liberty "without due process of law." One question remains: which court ever had proper jurisdiction?
Sources: Court filings in 1:23-cv-03773-AKH (S.D.N.Y.) and 1:23-cv-03773-OEM-TAM (E.D.N.Y.); PBS Frontline.
--- META --- Array ( [images] => Array ( ) [pdfs] => Array ( [0] => https://hnrlawlibrary.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Strike-3-Holdings-LLC-v.-John-Doe-Cover.pdf [1] => https://hnrlawlibrary.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/People-of-The-State-of-New-York-v.-Trump-5-4-23.pdf [2] => https://hnrlawlibrary.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Strike-3-Holdings-LLC-v.-John-Doe-5-19-23.pdf ) )