======================================== POST #26 ======================================== Title: State Insurance Fund v. Harry’s Nurses Registry: What Justice Tingling Actually Decided Slug: state-insurance-fund-v-harrys-nurses-registry-what-justice-tingling-actually-decided-26 Date: 2026-11-05 14:16:53 Status: publish Category: 2 YouTube: Image: https://hnrlawlibrary.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/harrys-406555-feature-7.jpg ======================================== --- SHORT SUMMARY --- Commissioners of the State Insurance Fund v. Harry’s Nurses Registry, Inc., Index No. 406555/07: On July 8, 2011, Justice Milton A. Tingling, Jr. denied the State Insurance Fund’s motion for summary judgment in its entirety. His decision notes that Harry’s reported 11 employees, while numerous “independent contractors” were paid $2,457,483. Harry’s maintains that its RNs and LPNs are 1099 independent contractors, and two administrative law judges agreed. The case documents, letters and rulings are linked in the article. --- CONTENT ---
WORKERS' COMPENSATION · INDEX NO. 406555/07
Commissioners of The State Insurance Fund vs. Harry's Nurses Registry, Inc.
Decision and Order, page 1
Court
Supreme Court of the State of New York, New York County
Justice
Hon. Milton A. Tingling, Jr.
Decision
July 8, 2011
Result
Plaintiff's motion for summary judgment denied in its entirety
PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENTS
U.S. DOL Wage and Hour Division and NYS Department of Labor, page 1
PDF
U.S. DOL Wage and Hour Division and NYS Department of Labor
Partnership agreement
Download PDF ↓
U.S. DOL Wage and Hour Division and NY Attorney General's Labor Bureau, page 1
PDF
U.S. DOL Wage and Hour Division and NY Attorney General's Labor Bureau
Partnership agreement
Download PDF ↓
1
Milton A. Tingling, Jr.
Hon. Milton A. Tingling, Jr.
Hon. Milton A. Tingling, Jr.
FORMER JUSTICE · NEW YORK COUNTY SUPREME COURT, CIVIL TERM
Born1954
EducationBrown University (B.A.); North Carolina Central University School of Law (J.D.)
Milton A. Tingling, Jr. is a former justice for the New York County Supreme Court, Civil Term in the 1st Judicial District of New York. He was elected to this position in 2001. He retired from the court on December 31, 2014, to become the New York County Clerk.
2
Harry's Nurses Are Independent Contractors
Harry's Nurses Registry's position on Judge Tingling's decision
HARRY'S NURSES REGISTRY'S POSITION
1
The State Insurance Fund policy ran from 2/7/2006 to 6/19/2007, more than a year. Therefore the short-rate premium is not applicable in this case.
2
Judge Tingling's decision records that the Fund based its premium on 11 employees who earned a total of $301,280 (see Plaintiff exhibit B, p 4), while the defendant "in fact employed numerous 'independent contractors' who were paid an aggregate of $2,457,483 from February 7 to June 30, 2006." Harry's position is that its field nurses are independent contractors under New York State law, and its workers' compensation obligation was limited to the 11 persons working daily in the office as salaried employees.
3
The AIG policy started on 5/25/2007, while the State Insurance Fund policy ran to 6/19/2007, creating double coverage for W-2 and 1099 workers. The Fund policy should have been cancelled when the AIG coverage began. Based on the letters from the New York State Insurance Fund, workers' compensation is not required for 1099 nurses.
4
According to Judge Tingling, the plaintiff's motion for summary judgment was denied in its entirety.
NY State Insurance Fund letter 1, page 1
PDF
NY State Insurance Fund letter 1
July 13, 2006 · premium review
Download PDF ↓
NY State Insurance Fund letter 2, page 1
PDF
NY State Insurance Fund letter 2
August 11, 2006 · 1099 workers
Download PDF ↓
Malicious Prosecution, page 1
PDF
Malicious Prosecution
Letter to the Queens County District Attorney
Download PDF ↓
3
Case #406555/07 Was Sent for Trial
Case #406555/07 was sent for trial. On the morning of trial, August 11, 2014, Justice Arthur F. Engoron denied the request of Harry's attorney to be relieved as counsel "solely as too late." The case was then settled.
Harry's contends that Attorney Richard A. Finkel acted inappropriately while he was responsible to work for the defendant as an attorney. According to Harry's, he reversed the Honorable Judge Milton A. Tingling's decision by agreeing to pay an additional $180,000 to the State Insurance Fund. Harry's views this as a misinterpretation and misrepresentation by Attorney Finkel, because the nurses at Harry's Nurses Registry are independent contractors and not subject to workers' compensation.
Order of Justice Arthur F. Engoron, page 1
IMG
Order of Justice Arthur F. Engoron
August 11, 2014 · Motion Seq. 06
View image →
Attorney Finkel's settlement letter, page 1
PDF
Attorney Finkel's settlement letter
August 25, 2014
Download PDF ↓
Notice of Default, Index No. 406555/07, page 1
PDF
Notice of Default, Index No. 406555/07
December 2, 2014
Download PDF ↓
4
Unemployment Insurance
Ruled as independent contractors
According to the administrative law judges below, nurses that work for Harry's Nurses Registry Inc. are independent contractors.
JB
Judge Jean Bell
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE · NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF LABOR
FindingNurses are independent contractors
“The credible evidence establishes that the employer did not exercise sufficient supervision, direction, or control over the services performed by the nurses to establish their status as employees.”
Judge Jean Bell
Although the nurses registered with the employer, the Department of Education can grant or revoke the nurses' privileges, while the hospital and nursing home decide the rate of pay, hours, and duties. The doctors at the hospitals and nursing homes provide guidance and instructions to the nurses and supervise their performance. The nurses are free to work on their own or for competing employers and agencies.
MM
Judge Manuel Marks
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
FindingNurses are independent contractors
The agency is an employment agency providing primarily nurses and licensed practical nurses to hospitals, nursing homes and private individuals. It advertises for nurses and registers those who respond. When a hospital, nursing home or private individual requests a nurse, the agency provides a list of candidates, the client chooses, and the agency negotiates a fee. The agency provides no supervision, training or instruction; supervision is provided by the facilities or individuals. The nurses provide their own transportation and supplies, are not reimbursed for expenses, and may be registered with other agencies at the same time.
Ruling by Judge Jean Bell, page 1
PDF
Ruling by Judge Jean Bell
Administrative Law Judge · NYS Department of Labor
Download PDF ↓
Ruling by Judge Manuel Marks, page 1
PDF
Ruling by Judge Manuel Marks
Administrative Law Judge
Download PDF ↓
Unemployment insurance ruling, page 1
PDF
Unemployment insurance ruling
Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board
Download PDF ↓
 
↗
nycourts.gov
 
WEB
Matter of Harry's Nurses Registry (2019)
Appellate Division, Third Department
Open page →
5
Related Documents
 
↗
law.justia.com
 
WEB
Nurses are independent contractors under Medicaid regulation
N.J. Appellate Division, 1990 · Justia
Open page →
Petition: Harry's Nurses Registry v. New York Department of Labor, page 1
PDF
Petition: Harry's Nurses Registry v. New York Department of Labor
Brief for Petitioner-Appellant · 25 pages
Download PDF ↓
--- META --- Array ( [images] => Array ( ) [pdfs] => Array ( ) )